HOW TO REGISTER FOR THE FORUM

Please contact the France & Colonies Philatelic Society webmaster (see contact information at the bottom of the page). We have had reports that some members using Microsoft Edge and older versions of Safari have had difficulties in logging in. We have found by changing browers to Chrome or Firefox has rectified the problem.

This is the optional category header for the Suggestion Box.

Display Validity

  • hfisher
  • Topic Author
11 years 1 month ago #26 by hfisher
Display Validity was created by hfisher
I have been asked to give a shortish display of French WW1 military postal history to my local philatelic society.
Of course, my main interest is France but I have several items of British Field Service and post cards which were sent from France by British soldiers. One series of 27 picture post cards are from the same man to the same girl and I have been able to identify both and the fact that they married in 1917 - an interesting piece of social history. (Maybe I should explain that I am, by qualification, a social historian).
My question is whether it would be valid to display some of my British Field Service cards (with their differing censor cachets) and a small selection of the above mentioned picture post cards, in a display of France in WW1 with appropriate explanations.
My inclination is to include the items since they originated in France but, of course, they did not use the French postal system being purely British military postal items.
I should be interested in the views of other members.
This is a display, not a competition entry so that might have a bearing on views.

Howard

Please Log in to join the conversation.

More
11 years 1 week ago #32 by mstyler
Replied by mstyler on topic Display Validity
I think you should feel free to display whatever material you like. My own interest in WWI includes anything that was posted in France and therefore includes military mail from the armies of other countries such as UK. I haven't yet displayed this latter material to the Society but may well do so at a future Charlecote weekend. As you suggest, there are rules in competitions that may well affect one's choice of items, but displays are intended to engage the interest of those viewing the material and can be as eclectic and eccentric as you like, provided they are coherent and tell a relevant story.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • hfisher
  • Topic Author
11 years 1 week ago #33 by hfisher
Replied by hfisher on topic Display Validity
Hello Maurice,

Thank you for your comments.
You state what I have decided as it does extend the scope and will be of interest, perhaps, to a wider section of the audience!

Howard

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • pallan
10 years 11 months ago #41 by pallan
Replied by pallan on topic Display Validity
Howard,
If it was a formal Exhibition with the usual rules you could probably legitimately display your British material if you worded the scope of the display accordingly. If its a Club display no-one would be in the least concerned ( based on my experience in Australia) about any deviation from formal Exhibition rules.
I certainly sounds as thouhg these items will make the display more interesting.
Peter

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • hfisher
  • Topic Author
10 years 11 months ago #42 by hfisher
Replied by hfisher on topic Display Validity
Many thanks Peter.
It is just a Club show so I will include without fretting about it!
Howard

Please Log in to join the conversation.

More
10 years 11 months ago #53 by prakelly
Replied by prakelly on topic Display Validity
My own view is that a display to a general society can be approached in a more liberal manner and if the material is interesting and has some french element then it is accetable.
When displaying to a french specialised society then it probably would not as the basic substance needs to be french which this is clearly not.
Just my opinion!

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.493 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum